A Renewal Is Not a Registration – vol 6.46

Ankur RahejaUDRP Case Summaries Leave a Comment

When Trademark Infringement Is Not Cybersquatting – Why Likelihood of Confusion Does Not Necessarily Establish Bad Faith Under the UDRP

by Ivan (Yitzchak) Lipshitz, Adv., JMB Davis Ben-David, Israel

 Introduction

A trademark practitioner discovering a domain name identical or confusingly similar to a client’s mark may instinctively conclude that the registrant is infringing the client’s trademark rights and that the domain name should be recoverable through the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (the “UDRP” or the “Policy”).

That instinct is understandable. Trademark lawyers are accustomed to assessing competing commercial identifiers through principles of priority, distinctiveness, reputation and likelihood of confusion. A domain name used by a competitor to market similar goods or services may present precisely the marketplace confusion that trademark law seeks to prevent.

Yet trademark infringement and cybersquatting are not coterminous legal concepts.

The UDRP was designed to address abusive domain name registration and use, not to provide an alternative forum for every dispute involving competing trademarks or commercial names. Conduct that may support an infringement action under national trademark law does not necessarily establish cybersquatting under the Policy. Continue reading article here. 


📅  November 19, 2026
🕘  9:00 a.m. PT | 12:00 p.m. ET
🔗 Register: https://lnkd.in/gV_i8BYQ


We hope you will enjoy this edition of the Digest (vol. 6.46) as we review these noteworthy recent decisions with expert commentary. (We invite guest commenters to contact us): 

‣ A Renewal Is Not a Registration (bcabenefitsgroup.com *with commentary) 

‣ No Response, No Shortcut: Panel Still Requires Proof of Targeting (sebim.com *with commentary) 

‣ Is Disparaging a Trademark Owner a Ground for Transfer? (yelplabs.com *with commentary) 

‣ A Finding of RDNH Is a Clear Basis for Redacting the Respondent’s Name, If Requested (sattamatka.email and sattamatka.sale *with commentary) 

‣ Two Rebels, No Cybersquatting (banklikearebel.online *with commentary) 


A Renewal Is Not a Registration

Digital Insurance LLC v. JIM BIANCHI / BCA FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., Forum Case No. FA2610002250504

<bcabenefitsgroup.com>

Panelist: Mr. Nicholas J.T. Smith

Brief Facts: The Complainant asserts common law rights in the BCA and BCA BENEFITS GROUP marks and an associated logo, based on use in connection with employee benefits management services since at least 2014. The Complainant asserts that it acquired these marks, their goodwill and the rights in the disputed Domain Name under a July 2018 Asset Purchase Agreement (“APA”) with the principals of the BCA business, one of whom is the Respondent. According to the Complainant, the Respondent registered the disputed Domain Name in his own name in 2014. The Respondent did so while serving as managing partner of the BCA business, before its sale to the Complainant. The Complainant states that the Respondent kept control of the registration after leaving the Complainant in 2022, and that he renewed it in August 2026 despite the Complainant’s demand for its transfer.

The Complainant alleges that the Respondent’s use of the disputed Domain Name to promote a competing business under confusingly similar branding is not a bona fide offering of services and is intended to attract Internet users for commercial gain by creating confusion as to affiliation with the Complainant. The Complainant further alleges that the Respondent renewed the registration in August 2026 with actual knowledge of the Complainant’s rights and no basis under the APA to retain it, thereby satisfying the bad faith registration requirement, and cites seven decisions in support, including Documo Inc. v. Matthew Herrera (now known as Matthew Valeo), WIPO Case No. DIO2023-0024; the Respondent did not file a Response.

Held: The Panel finds that the Complainant has failed to meet its burden of proof of bad faith registration and therefore has not satisfied Policy ¶ 4(a)(iii) (Tristar Products, Inc. v. Domain Administrator / Telebrands, Corp., FA 1597388). On the Complainant’s own account, the Respondent registered the disputed Domain Name in 2014 as managing partner of the business trading under the BCA marks. The record does not establish that any common law rights had accrued by then. Even if they had, those rights would have belonged to the BCA business, from which the Complainant claims to have acquired them. There is no evidence that the Respondent acted in bad faith when he registered the disputed Domain Name.

UDRP case law has overwhelmingly rejected the argument that a renewal, together with a failure to transfer under the APA, amounts to bad faith registration. Mere renewal by the same registrant is insufficient (WIPO Overview 3.1, section 3.9). The Complainant is legally represented and cites seven decisions, so it should be well aware of this. The Complainant’s reliance on Documo is misplaced, because that case was decided under the .IO policy, which allows a finding based on bad faith use alone. Even if keeping the disputed Domain Name were sharp conduct in breach of the APA, it would go only to use, not registration (Platterz v. Andrew Melcher, FA 1729887).

This is not a case of cybersquatting. It is a business dispute over a contract entered into several years after the disputed Domain Name was registered, and it falls outside the scope of the Policy (Everingham Bros. Bait Co. v. Contigo Visual, FA 440219; Fuze Beverage, LLC v. CGEYE, Inc., FA 844252). Other remedies may be available to the Complainant in a forum that can determine and enforce its rights under the APA. Nothing in the decision is a definitive finding on the parties’ respective rights.

RDNH: At a minimum, items (i) and (iii) of WIPO Overview 3.1, section 4.16 are present. The Complainant knew that the Respondent registered the disputed Domain Name in 2014 as managing partner of the business it later acquired. That was likely before any common law rights arose, and any such rights would in any case have belonged to that business. The Complainant should therefore have known it could not establish bad faith registration. The Complainant had sophisticated counsel, who cited six UDRP decisions and one .IO decision. The Complainant nonetheless rested its case on the theory that renewal amounted to re-registration, which is contrary to well-settled case law it did not address. Instead, the Complainant “cherry-picks a single case from 2013” (Bear River Mutual Insurance Company v. Dzone Inc., FA 1528522).

At paragraph 41 of the Complaint, the Complainant quoted Documo and emphasised the words stating that either bad faith registration or bad faith use need be shown, without explaining that the policy referred to there was the .IO policy, even though the sentence immediately before it in Documo distinguishes the two policies. At paragraph 42, the Complainant relied on Documo for the proposition that refusing to transfer a validly assigned domain name is bad faith, although Documo found that refusal to be bad faith use, which suffices under the .IO policy but not under the UDRP. Read together, those paragraphs misrepresent what Documo establishes under paragraph 4(a)(iii). The Complainant, therefore, failed to comply with its certification under Rule 3(b)(xiii) that the Complaint was complete and accurate and its assertions warranted.

Together with the circumstances of the original registration and the reliance on renewal, this means the Complaint was brought in bad faith. It constitutes an attempt at Reverse Domain Name Hijacking and an abuse of the administrative proceeding.

Complaint Denied (RDNH)

Complainant’s Counsel: Ashley N. Klein of Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP, United States
Respondent’s Counsel: No Response

Commentary by ICA General Counsel, Zak Muscovitch:

The Complainant’s case on bad faith registration rested on the Respondent’s August 2026 renewal of a Domain Name he had registered in 2014. The Panel rejected the argument expressly, noting that the position “has been overwhelmingly rejected by case law under the Policy”. That is an accurate statement of where the case law stands. The renewal theory is closely related to the “retroactive bad faith” decisions of 2009 and 2010, and the rejection of both by panels in the years that followed is traced in the ICA’s article, The Rise and Fall of the UDRP Theory of “Retroactive Bad Faith” (CircleID, May 8, 2017). The WIPO Overview 3.1, at section 3.9, records that panels have found that “the mere renewal of a domain name registration by the same registrant is insufficient to support a finding of registration in bad faith”. The Panel was right to say so in plain terms.

The Panel appropriately found RDNH, and the renewal theory was a large part of the reason. The Panel noted that the Complainant was represented by counsel and cited seven decisions, yet relied on a single 2013 decision for the renewal theory without acknowledging the overwhelming precedent to the contrary. The Panel also found that the Complainant presented a decision under the .IO policy, where bad faith registration or use suffices, in a “materially incomplete and misleading way”, and that it failed to comply with its certification under Rule 3(b)(xiii). UDRP Perspectives, §4.2 (When a Finding of RDNH is Appropriate) describes both kinds of case, namely complaints brought where the complainant knew or ought to have known that it could not succeed, and “breach of certification” cases. The Panel did so even though no Response was filed. As UDRP Perspectives, §4.1 (Obligation of Panelists to Consider RDNH) explains, a Panelist must still consider RDNH where appropriate, even in no-response cases.

The Panel was also correct that this was never a case of cybersquatting. On the Complainant’s own account, the Respondent registered the Domain Name in 2014 as managing partner of the business that traded under the BCA name, four years before the Complainant acquired that business. The Panel’s analysis on this point was spot on. Even if common law rights had existed in 2014, they “would have belonged to the BCA business”, which the Respondent was then running. It is hard to see how, in these circumstances, a registrant targets a mark by registering a domain name for the business that owns it. Whether the asset purchase agreement obliges the Respondent to hand over the Domain Name is a contract question for a court, as the Panel noted. As UDRP Perspectives, §3.9 (Prior Business Relationship) explains, such disputes may involve a domain name registered in good faith in furtherance of the business relationship and then, according to the complainant, repurposed for a bad faith use after the relationship ends. Since the Policy requires both bad faith registration and use, such a complaint would typically fail.


No Response, No Shortcut: Panel Still Requires Proof of Targeting

SEBIM v. kang-woo,lee, WIPO Case No. D2026-4278

<sebim.com>

Panelist: Ms. Kathryn Lee

Brief Facts: The Complainant is a French company specializing in highly engineered valves, pumps and actuators. The Complainant has used SEBIM as the brand name for its safety valves since the 1960s, with evidence of nuclear contracts awarded to SEBIM in 1983 for export to the Republic of Korea. Acquired by FRAMATOME in 2026, it changed its corporate name to SEBIM effective June 2, 2026. The Complainant owns figurative marks for GROUPE SEBIM: French trademark (September 24, 2010) and EU trademark (June 23, 2011). The Complainant also owns <sebim.fr>, registered April 13, 2007. The Respondent, apparently based in South Korea, is linked to a domain sales site and 768 domain names through a reverse WhoIs search. The disputed Domain Name was registered on November 7, 2010 and does not resolve to an active website. A 2013 archived capture shows a generic page offering it for sale, and a Sedo listing captured on September 15, 2026 invited offers with a minimum of USD $9,860.

The Complainant alleges that the Respondent has no rights or legitimate interests, relying on the absence of an active website and the Respondent’s activity as a seller of domain names. The Complainant also alleges bad faith registration and use. On this point it relies on the distinctiveness and history of the SEBIM brand, its use in the Republic of Korea since the 1980s, the proximity of the registration to its trademark applications of April 6 and September 13, 2010, and the establishment of a Korean group subsidiary on December 29, 2010. The Complainant further relies on passive holding, the Respondent’s portfolio of other domain names allegedly corresponding to third-party marks, and the sale negotiations. The Complainant states that its agent offered USD $10,000 in February 2026 and received a counteroffer of USD $2,334,339. The Respondent did not reply to the Complainant’s contentions.

Held: The Complainant’s French trademark registration and its historical use of the GROUPE SEBIM mark predate the registration of the disputed Domain Name. The Panel has considered the mark’s distinctiveness and its historical use in the specialist industrial sector. The brochure referring to a 1983 export contract to the Republic of Korea does not sufficiently establish that the Respondent was likely to have known of the brand in 2010. Nor does the proximity of the registration to the trademark applications establish knowledge by itself. The Korean subsidiary was incorporated after the disputed Domain Name was registered. There is no evidence that the Respondent knew of its planned establishment or of any connection between that subsidiary and the mark. In addition, panels have found that the practice of registering a domain name for resale does not by itself support a claim that the respondent registered the domain name in bad faith with the primary purpose of selling it to the trademark owner (or its competitor).

The disputed Domain Name is a short, five-letter designation that can be pronounced in two syllables. It may appeal for uses unrelated to the Complainant, although that does not establish that the Respondent selected it for such a purpose. The negotiations were initiated by the Complainant’s agent, and the correspondence does not establish that the Respondent knew the prospective buyer was the Complainant. The counteroffer is substantial, but even on the Complainant’s account, an amount sought in 2026 does not show that the Respondent selected the disputed Domain Name in 2010 to exploit the Complainant’s mark without further evidence of targeting. Although the Respondent’s portfolio raises some questions, apart from a few outliers, the vast majority of its hundreds of domain names consist of dictionary or descriptive terms, with nothing targeting the Complainant’s industry or suggesting knowledge of the Complainant. On the balance of probabilities, the Respondent did not register the disputed Domain Name to target the Complainant, and the third element has not been established.

Complaint Denied

Complainant’s Counsel: Cabinet Lavoix, France
Respondent’s Counsel: No Response  

Commentary by ICA General Counsel, Zak Muscovitch:

The significance of this decision lies in the fact that no response was filed, and yet the Panel made its own findings on the evidence and appropriately denied the Complaint. The Respondent’s silence left the Complainant’s account unchallenged, including an alleged counteroffer of USD $2,334,339 and a portfolio said to include third-party marks. The Panel did not treat that silence as proof. As UDRP Perspectives, §0.8 (Inferences in No Response Cases) explains, even in no-response cases Panels must evaluate the allegations and the evidence presented to determine whether the Complainant has proven each of the Policy’s three elements, and may only draw reasonable inferences that are supported by evidence rather than inferences drawn from a mere failure to respond. The Panel did so here, and with care.

On knowledge, the Panel noted that the Complainant’s valves are sold in a specialist industrial sector and that a 1983 export contract to the Republic of Korea did not establish that the Respondent was likely to have known of the brand in 2010. The proximity of the registration to the trademark filings was not enough by itself, and the Korean subsidiary was incorporated only after the Domain Name was registered. The Panel also noted that other parties use “sebim”, including a French string instrument maker and a Turkish software company, and that a short, pronounceable five-letter name may have appeal for uses unrelated to the Complainant. As UDRP Perspectives, §3.3 (Targeting) explains, the onus is on the Complainant to provide evidence of the Respondent’s intention to target a specific Complainant rather than anyone who may have a trademark for the corresponding term.

The Panel took the same care with the portfolio evidence. It acknowledged that a few of the Respondent’s other registrations “raise some questions”, but it looked at the portfolio as a whole. The vast majority of the hundreds of domain names corresponded to dictionary or descriptive terms, and there was no apparent targeting of the Complainant’s industry. A few outliers did not establish that this particular Domain Name was registered to target this Complainant.

On price, the Panel noted that the Complainant’s agent initiated the negotiations and that the correspondence did not establish that the Respondent knew the prospective buyer was the Complainant. The Panel accepted that the alleged counteroffer was “substantial”. It nonetheless found that the amount sought in 2026 does not, without further evidence of targeting, establish that the Respondent selected the Domain Name in 2010 to exploit the Complainant’s mark. As UDRP Perspectives, §3.5 (Setting a Price and Offering for Sale) explains, an inference drawn from an asking price is best treated as confirming or undercutting a finding drawn from other evidence, rather than as the primary basis for a finding.


Is Disparaging a Trademark Owner a Ground for Transfer?

Yelp Inc. v. Max Lim / Cash Cash Inc., Forum Case No. FA2610002251202

<yelplabs.com>

Panelist: The Honorable Neil Anthony Brown KC

Brief Facts: The Complainant is a United States company that has provided a popular local research and review platform and related goods and services under its YELP trademark since at least 2004, using <yelp.com> as its official website. The Complainant owns USPTO registration for YELP, registered on November 26, 2013, and numerous other registrations for YELP. The Respondent, located in the Philippines, registered the disputed Domain Name on December 28, 2023. The Respondent’s website bears the heading “Yelp Labs Beating Yelp Since 2017,” criticizes the Complainant’s algorithm for approving negative reviews while burying positive ones in its “not recommended” section, and offers the Respondent’s services at the rates set out on the site.

The Complainant alleges that the Respondent uses the disputed Domain Name to sell fake reviews, in violation of United States federal and state law and in breach of the Complainant’s Terms of Service. The Complainant further alleges that the disputed Domain Name was registered and used to disparage the Complainant, is directed against its genuine services, and is designed to generate confusion. On bad faith, the Complainant relies on the disruption of its business under Policy ¶ 4(b)(iii) and on the false impression of affiliation under Policy ¶ 4(b)(iv). The Complainant also relies on a business model based on deception, the use of a privacy shield service, and the Respondent’s actual knowledge of the Complainant and its trademark. The Respondent did not file a Response.

Held: The Respondent registered the disputed Domain Name several years after the Complainant began offering its services and well after the Complainant acquired its trademark rights. The precise mechanics are not entirely clear from the evidence. Even so, the Wayback Machine record shows that for several years the Respondent has used the disputed Domain Name for a purpose that could not give it a right or legitimate interest. The Exhibit 5 shows the Respondent asserting that its service is better than the Complainant’s and that the Complainant’s algorithm is bad. It also shows the Respondent offering, for money, to manipulate reviews so that positive ones gain prominence and negative ones lose it. As the reviews can only be bought by subscription, they are in all probability fake, as a panel concluded on similar facts in Yelp Inc. v. Mahammad Sabuz, FA 2004970. The Respondent uses the YELP trademark to denigrate the Complainant’s business, to compete with it and for financial benefit. That conduct is entirely illegitimate, and it is not a bona fide offering of goods and services under Policy ¶ 4(c)(i).

The Respondent used the domain name to disparage the Complainant and its business, and to offer for sale reviews that are in all probability fake. The Respondent’s intention must, therefore, have been to induce prospective customers to take their business to the Respondent instead, which disrupts the Complainant’s business under Policy ¶ 4(b)(iii). The website pages in Exhibit 5 carry no disclaimer. The website is therefore open to the interpretation that it may be affiliated with the Complainant, which gives rise to confusion under Policy ¶ 4(b)(iv). The Respondent’s business model is based on deception and misleading internet users, which is inherently in bad faith. Offering and providing such reviews for money breaches United States federal and state law and the Complainant’s Terms of Service, and that conduct is bad faith. At all material times the Respondent had actual knowledge of the Complainant and its trademark, without which it could not have carried out its subterfuge.

Transfer

Complainant’s Counsel: Reed Lyon of Yelp Inc., United States
Respondent’s Counsel: No Response

Commentary by ICA General Counsel, Zak Muscovitch:

The Panel found that the Respondent used the Domain Name “to disparage the Complainant and offer for sale reviews that are in all probability fake”. It is worth asking which of those two findings supports the transfer. Selling fake reviews, if that is what the Respondent was doing, is not a bona fide offering of goods or services, and the Respondent’s claim to a legitimate interest would fail on that finding alone. Bad faith registration and use must still be established separately. The website’s statements that it has been “Beating Yelp Since 2017” and that “Yelp’s Algorithm Sucks” are of a different kind. They are criticism, and the Policy does not treat criticism of a trademark owner as illegitimate or as evidence of bad faith.

Paragraph 4(c)(iii) of the Policy protects “a legitimate noncommercial or fair use of the domain name, without intent for commercial gain to misleadingly divert consumers or to tarnish the trademark or service mark at issue”. The Respondent’s use was commercial, so the safe harbour would turn on whether the Respondent intended to misleadingly divert consumers or to tarnish the mark. The Panel found confusion under paragraph 4(b)(iv) because the website carried no disclaimer and was therefore “open to the interpretation that it may well be affiliated with the Complainant”. That paragraph, however, requires that a respondent “intentionally attempted to attract” Internet users “by creating a likelihood of confusion”. Would a visitor who is told that the site has been “Beating Yelp” and that Yelp’s algorithm “sucks” take the site to be Yelp’s own? The Domain Name itself may nevertheless suggest affiliation, since, as the Panel noted under the first element, “Yelp Labs” may be taken to mean the work of the Complainant in its own laboratories or workshops. Similarly, paragraph 4(b)(iii) concerns registration “primarily for the purpose of disrupting the business of a competitor”, and it may be asked whether a seller of reviews competes with the platform on which reviews are posted. The WIPO Overview 3.1, at section 3.1.3, records that panels have applied the notion of a competitor to include “a person who acts in opposition to another” for commercial gain, and the Panel’s finding is consistent with that approach.

As UDRP Perspectives, §2.10 (Free Speech and Criticism Sites) explains, panels should not evaluate the nature of criticism, whether it is correct or incorrect, defamatory, reasonable or outrageous, and should instead determine whether the domain name was registered and used as a mere sham or pretext. On that approach, the Respondent’s criticism of Yelp would count against it only if it were a pretext for the sale of fake reviews.

A business that offers services relating to a trademark owner’s platform may also need to use the mark to say so. UDRP Perspectives, §2.3 (Nominative Fair Use) notes that under the more holistic approach adopted by some panelists, the absence of a prominent disclaimer does not necessarily make a respondent’s use illegitimate, and panels look at the domain name composition and at website content that may either confirm or deny affiliation with the complainant. Here the Panel acknowledged that it was “not entirely clear from the evidence as to how this has been done or the extent to which it has been done”, and it inferred that the reviews were fake because they could only be bought by subscription. If that inference is right, the Respondent had no legitimate interest whatever it said about Yelp. The third element would still require that the Domain Name was registered and used in bad faith. Had the service been a lawful one, the Respondent’s criticism of Yelp and its reference to the YELP mark would not by themselves have supported a transfer.


A Finding of RDNH Is a Clear Basis for Redacting the Respondent’s Name, If Requested

Rikshiram Aghria v. Name Redacted, WIPO Case No. D2026-4111

<sattamatka.email> and <sattamatka.sale>

Panelist: Ms. Harini Narayanswamy

Brief Facts: The Complainant is an individual in Odisha, India, who relies on three Indian device marks: SATTA (Class 28, dated July 13, 2023), SATTA MATKA (Class 35, dated June 30, 2023) and SATTA MATKA (Class 41, dated July 15, 2023). The Respondents are named as two separate individuals, but acknowledged that they have common control over both the disputed Domain Names. <sattamatka.email> was registered on September 25, 2020, and <sattamatka.sale> on July 12, 2023. The Respondents are using the disputed Domain Names in connection with websites that display results, information, analytics and charts pertaining to “Satta Matka”. A disclaimer at the bottom of the <sattamatka.sale> web page states “The information provided on SattaMatka.sale is based purely on numerical calculations and astrology for informational purposes. All data is gathered from public domains on the internet. We are not associated with any illegal gaming, betting or gambling businesses”.

The Complainant alleges that his marks are distinctive and coined, that the Respondent trades on them in the gaming field covered by his Class 28 registration, and that the disputed Domain Names are being used, or are intended to be used, for satta matka gambling, which is prohibited under Section 5 of India’s Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025. In its reply to the Respondent’s supplemental submission, the Complainant further asserts that the 2023 re-registration of <sattamatka.sale> was a fresh registration made 12 days after his applications were filed. The Respondent contends that the <sattamatka.email> predates the marks, relying on a Google AdSense communication of April 8, 2021 and third-party search records, and that the term has long been in common use in India. The Respondent also contends that he re-registered <sattamatka.sale> under the same customer account to continue his earlier project, that he was unaware of the Complainant’s trademark, and that no bets, wagers or stakes are accepted, and no winnings paid, through <sattamatka.sale>.

Preliminary Issues: (a) Redaction – The Respondents have requested that their names be redacted from the published decision because it does not wish those names to appear in connection with the Complainant’s allegations of illegal activity. Considering this request and the circumstances of this case, including that the Panel does not determine the allegations of illegal activity, the Panel has redacted the names of the Respondents from this decision. (b) Consolidation – The Panel finds the Respondents have acknowledged that both the disputed Domain Names are under common control. The Panel sees no reason why consolidation of the disputes would be unfair or inequitable to any Party. Accordingly, the Panel decides to consolidate the disputes regarding the nominally different disputed Domain Name registrants in a single proceeding.

Held: The Panel finds that the material on record shows that, before receiving notice of the dispute, the Respondent used the disputed Domain Names to publish information, numbers, results, and analytical charts relating to the “satta matka” game. The Respondent has provided evidence of such use of <sattamatka.email> for a few years before the filing of the Complainant’s trademark applications. The evidence on record shows that the Respondent’s use of the disputed Domain Names corresponds to the meaning of the term “satta matka” and does not exploit or target the Complainant’s trademark. However, whether the websites breach India’s Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025, is a matter for a court of competent jurisdiction to decide, not the UDRP (WIPO Overview 3.1, section 4.14.6). The second element has not been established.

On the third element, the Complainant’s marks were filed in June and July 2023. That was after <sattamatka.email> was registered in 2020, and after <sattamatka.sale> was first registered in 2022. The marks are stylized device marks filed on a proposed-use basis, and there is no evidence of use or of common law rights before the filings. The marks are inherently descriptive and not coined or unique as claimed. To show targeting by the July 12, 2023 re-registration of <sattamatka.sale>, the Complainant needed evidence of significant use of its marks in the 12 days after filing, and it filed none. The Respondent’s earlier registration of <sattamatka.email> supports the conclusion that the re-registration of <sattamatka.sale> reflected a pre-existing interest in the term, not a reaction to the trademark applications. Because “satta” and “satta matka” are generic and descriptive, the burden of proving prior rights in descriptive marks as a source identifier on the Complainant is much higher than for a unique or a coined mark. The Respondent did not register the domain names in bad faith to target, impersonate or copy the Complainant’s marks, and the third element has not been established.

RDNH: The Complainant knew that <sattamatka.email> was registered before its trademark filings and that both domain names consist of common words. The Complainant still filed the Complaint with no evidence that its marks had acquired secondary meaning, relying only on unsupported allegations. The Respondent’s registration and use show no attempt to impersonate, copy or exploit the Complainant’s marks. The Complaint was brought in bad faith and constitutes an attempt at Reverse Domain Name Hijacking.

Complaint Denied (RDNH)

Complainant’s Counsel: Self-represented
Respondent’s Counsel: Self-represented

Commentary by ICA General Counsel, Zak Muscovitch:

The Panel denied the Complaint and found that it was brought in bad faith and constituted an attempt at Reverse Domain Name Hijacking. The Panel also redacted the Respondents’ names from the published decision at their request. The Respondents did not wish their names to appear in connection with the Complainant’s allegations of illegal gambling activity. The Panel granted the request having regard to “the circumstances of this case”, including that it “does not determine the allegations of illegal activity”. Although the Panel did not expressly rely on its RDNH finding in deciding to redact the Respondents’ names, that finding provides a further reason why redaction was appropriate.

Allegations of illegality are harmful, and they are not the only reason redaction was warranted here. An unfounded allegation of cybersquatting is harmful enough. A published decision stays on the internet indefinitely, and the respondent’s name is in its title. Anyone who searches that name will find that the person was accused of registering a domain name in bad faith. The vindication comes only at the end of the decision, for those who read that far, and some readers will suspect wrongdoing from the mere fact that the person was named in a complaint at all. Where the complaint was an abuse of the proceeding, a complainant who unjustly attempted to get the domain name for itself still leaves its accusations attached to the respondent’s name permanently.

A finding of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking is accordingly a clear basis for redacting the respondent’s name where the respondent requests it. Little would be lost. The decision, its reasoning, the domain name and the complainant’s name would remain public, and the case law would be just as useful to parties and panels. The identity of a respondent who was the target of an abusive complaint adds little to it.

Paragraph 4(j) of the Policy provides that decisions will be published in full “except when an Administrative Panel determines in an exceptional case to redact portions of its decision”. As UDRP Perspectives, §0.18 (Redaction) explains, Panels may redact a respondent’s name where its publication may adversely affect his or her rights, and other information can be redacted in other exceptional circumstances, though the Policy allows this in “exceptional” cases only. A case of Reverse Domain Name Hijacking is an exceptional case. Such findings are few in relation to the entire body of complaints and the nature of the finding itself is exceptional in that it finds abusive conduct by a complainant. As John Berryhill has pointed out on numerous occasions, Panelists should not be used as tools of unscrupulous complainants by unjustly naming respondents on the Internet forever.

Panels have not been uniform on this. In <redmountain.com> (Digest Vol. 6.7), the Panel found RDNH but declined the respondent’s request for redaction, as it saw no evidence that the complainant’s goal was to harm the respondent’s name and did not consider the name unusual enough to justify the concern. The Final Report of the WIPO-ICA UDRP Review Project, published in December 2025, noted that, outside of identity theft cases, redaction is a matter for the panel’s discretion. The present decision shows that discretion being exercised in a respondent’s favour.


Two Rebels, No Cybersquatting

Belfius Bank SA / Belfius Bank NV v. Aloha Pacific Federal Credit Union, WIPO Case No. D2026-4140

<banklikearebel.online>

Panelist: Mr. Stefan Bojovic

 Brief Facts: The Complainant is a Belgian bank and financial services provider, 100 per cent owned by the government, with more than 5,000 employees and over 650 agencies. Its activities are focused on Belgium. The Complainant has developed an investment platform and application under the name RE=BEL. It owns the Benelux trademark (February 2, 2021) and European Union trademark registration (March 18, 2025) for RE=BEL, as well as domain names such as <rebel-be.com>. The Respondent is a not-for-profit credit union based in Hawaii and founded in 1936. It operates on three Hawaiian islands and has two branches in Nevada, and it does no business outside those two states.

The Respondent’s Rebels CU division, named after the University of Nevada Las Vegas (“UNLV”) Rebels athletic teams and mascot, opened a campus branch in January 2026. The Respondent owns the United States trademark for REBELS CU, registered on May 19, 2026, and states that it owns domain names such as <rebelscu.com>, registered on January 7, 2025. The disputed Domain Name was registered on July 4, 2025. When the Complaint was filed, it resolved to an inactive page. It now resolves to a parking page with pay-per-click links stating that the page is under construction.

The Complainant alleges that the Respondent knew or should have known of the earlier-registered RE=BEL trademark, which a good-faith search would readily have revealed, and that the addition of “bank,” which relates directly to its banking business and RE=BEL application, demonstrates such awareness. The Complainant further invokes passive holding, relying on the absence of an active website or legitimate business, the Respondent’s use of a privacy service, and the lack of any response to a cease-and-desist letter sent on August 17, 2026, to the Registrar’s abuse email address.

The Respondent contends that it chose “Rebels” in reference to UNLV’s mascot and athletic teams, registered the disputed Domain Name alongside other “rebel” and “rebels” domain names for its Rebels CU business, and relies on its REBELS CU registration. The Respondent further contends that neither it nor its management knew of the Complainant or its mark before receiving notice from Network Solutions’ Abuse Department, that the parties operate in geographically separate markets, and that neither is legally eligible to provide financial services in the other’s area.

Held: The Respondent did provide a Response, rebutting the Complainant’s arguments and providing relevant evidence demonstrating rights or legitimate interests in the disputed Domain Name. Both parties operate in banking and finance, but in different geographical markets. Neither RE=BEL nor REBELS CU is the parties’ primary brand, and both are recently launched services with limited geographical reach. It is therefore entirely plausible that each party conducts its legitimate business without being aware of the other or the other’s trademark. The Respondent’s United States registration for REBELS CU, together with its business under that name, supports its rights or legitimate interests. “Rebel” is not identical to REBELS CU, but it is a variation of the most distinctive portion of the Respondent’s mark, namely its singular form (WIPO Overview 3.1, section 2.12.1). The Respondent’s mark and branch postdate the Complainant’s mark by several years. However, the parties more likely than not do business on different continents unaware of each other, and the REBELS CU registration was not made to circumvent the Complainant’s rights (WIPO Overview 3.1, section 2.12.2).

The Respondent operates a legitimate business under REBELS CU, and the parties operate in geographically distinct markets. The Respondent also gave a credible explanation for choosing “Rebels”, by reference to UNLV’s athletic teams and mascot. In accordance with the above, the evidence in the case file as presented does not indicate that the Respondent’s aim in registering the disputed Domain Name was to profit from or exploit the Complainant’s trademark. With regard to the use of the disputed Domain Name in bad faith, the Panel finds that the circumstances of the present case do not warrant the application of the passive holding doctrine. The Respondent’s credible explanation is supported by evidence of genuine business activity, and its non-use is not sufficient for a finding of bad faith. That explanation also provides a plausible basis for future good-faith use. The current parking page with PPC links does not alter this, absent evidence that the links target the Complainant or its mark. The third element has not been established.

Complaint Denied

Complainant’s Counsel: Internally Represented
Respondent’s Counsel: Watanabe Ing LLP, United States

Commentary by ICA General Counsel, Zak Muscovitch:

This Complaint was brought by one legitimate financial institution against another. The Complainant is a Belgian bank with an investment platform called RE=BEL. The Respondent is a Hawaii credit union that holds a United States trademark registration for REBELS CU and operates a branch of that name at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, named after the university’s Rebels athletic teams. The Panel found it “entirely plausible that both parties are conducting their legitimate businesses unaware of each other” and denied the Complaint on the second and third elements. That was the correct result.

The Panel decided the case on its merits, and the case also shows where the scope of the Policy ends. As UDRP Perspectives, §0.1 (Scope of the Policy) explains, the UDRP is designed and intended only for clear cut cases of cybersquatting, and should not be applied to “good faith disputes between competing right holders or other competing legitimate interests”. Both parties here hold registered trademarks and use them for real services. If there is a dispute between them at all, it is a trademark dispute. Whatever questions might arise under applicable trademark law, the record disclosed no basis for treating this independently adopted business name as an act of cybersquatting.

The Panel found it unlikely that the Respondent registered the Domain Name “with the Complainant and its trademark in mind”. As UDRP Perspectives, §0.19 (Trademark Infringement) explains, cybersquatting requires intent whereas trademark infringement does not, and a respondent who merely happens to use a domain name that is similar to a complainant’s trademark, even for similar services, may not be cybersquatting if it did so without any intent to specifically target that trademark. Where a dispute involves competing claims of trademark rights, Panels should exercise caution in ensuring that the case is appropriate for resolution under the UDRP, which is not intended to provide a route around trademark infringement court actions.


Disclaimer: The facts are taken from the decisions themselves and have not been independently verified. The editors and publishers accept no responsibility for their accuracy.


Ankur Raheja is the Editor-in-Chief of the ICA’s new weekly UDRP Case Summary service. Ankur has practiced law in India since 2005 and has been practicing domain name law for over ten years, representing clients from all over the world in UDRP proceedings. He is the founder of Cylaw Solutions. 

He is an accredited panelist with ADNDRC (Hong Kong) and MFSD (Italy). Previously, Ankur worked as an Arbitrator/Panelist with .IN Registry for six years. In a advisory capacity, he has worked with NIXI/.IN Registry and Net4 India’s resolution professional.


This Digest was prepared using UDRP.Tools and the resources: Library of UDRP & ACPA Materials | The Clash of Trademarks and Domain Names on the Internet (by Mr. Gerald M. Levine), access digital edition on request. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *